Please review my new site design

[ausnrl]

Can someone please review my new site design. I kind of only want good comments but if your going to say something thats bad dont say like a big paragraph. Cheers

http://www.nrlleague.com

[Masterslave]

I get a Javascript error.
I don't like the 3D thing in your menu.
The header image is way too big.
The "Latest on NRLLeague" is annoying, is has scrollbars, it's very very annoying.
Everything isn't line out well, please use a ruler to line out your site...

In other words, I don't like your site, actually it's horrible.:o

[MarvinHalliwell]

I Agree that the logo is Maybe a bit to tall, and a inch wide.

But Hay, its a good site layout. Wish we all had the ability to design and keep a site theme. Unlike Some People.

Well Done, Good Job Ausnrl, Keep up the good work.

After all this is how good webdesigners start off.

[blain]

I wouldn't go as far as to say that the site is horrible but it does need a few changes made.

Lose the scroll bars in the centre box.
The three box headings (Login, Latest on league, results) don't line up vertically and are not as wide as the rest of the site when lined up.

The header image is wider than the rest of the site

Consider adding hover states to the menu buttons,

When you break up an article on your homepage, let people know by adding a keep reading button or something.

[Pennimus]

I'm getting a database error.

EDIT : Also, I find this particularly ridiculous...

I kind of only want good comments

[evo]

Lil Bronco, stop critising other people with abusive intent.

[jkd]

Deleted the bronco's posts.

[brett7481]

I agree with the above comments, but also in Opera your dropdown menu gets hidden behind your center scrollbar section.

[oracleguy]

I'd also suggest adding to your title image or some place obvious what NRL is just to make it more clear to visitors.

[Masterslave]

Dude, let me say one thing, I don't care if you think my site is crap. My site is UNDER CONSTRUCTION, if you can read so maybe are some things clear to you now.

I know what is a good website, I'm working for a webdevelopment company and we have won several prices including for best usability. So I'm know what I'm talking about.

Personally, I think that Masterslave wouldn't like it if people critised his website with only like 2 people giving good comments about it. It's good that you guys are giving advice but you could atleast congratulate him with his work even though you think it isn't that great.So am I right, you say that everybody must say it is a good website, even it isn't actualy good. If you agree with that, this section of CodingForums is useless. Maybe you should read this again (http://www.codingforums.com/showthread.php?t=36342).

NOFL but what you say is stupid.

[brett7481]

You people are horrible! I thought this community was good but I thought wrong......shame on all of you!

Great Job on the site ausnrl I think it's great. Keep it up man and don't let these people get your hopes down because they are just a bunch of internet randoms that don't know what they are talking about.

This site is not a site to bolster peoples self-esteem, it is not a "compliments only" site, it is not a site where we lie to people.

ausnrl, (LiL_BronCo) asked for a site review. That's what we did. If something is wrong with your site wouldn't you want to know? We are not internet randoms, quite a few of us are design professionals, so we know what we're talking about. Listening to what we have to say would make your website better, or at the very least more usable.

Simple fact of the matter is, if you want ONLY good comments, you should not post here. We take time to help you improve your site, we don't have the time to make you feel all warm and fluffy on the inside.